Gallery: so which did you choose?
Art and life are subjective. Not everybody’s gonna dig what I dig, but I reserve the right to dig it.Whoopi Goldberg
Photography, like all arts, is a subjective business. We all have our favourites. At times though it seems it’s almost as hard to judge other people’s work as it is our own. Nevertheless, we often do just that.
A while ago I posted some of my favourite shots from 2022, in response to John’s Lens Artists challenge. I organised them into several categories. But at the time I wasn’t sure which single one in each category was my number one favourite, so I asked you to choose. Some of you were reluctant to do so, but many did. Thank you all!
I promised to share the ‘winners’ in due course, hence this follow-up post. Interestingly, the exercise of asking you to pick a favourite in each category also led to me looking more closely and in most cases finding that I did have a preference after all. So below I share not only your winners but also my own, where they differed from the majority choice. I hope you’ll find it interesting to see the outcome of this exercise, and to compare your own choices, if you made them, with the final results and with mine.
Note: not everyone voted in every category so the totals for each vary.
Your clear winner: The Cellarium, Fountains Abbey
(9 votes out of 16)
My own choice: Staircase in the Palace National Art Gallery, Sofia
Flowers and plants
Your clear winner: Fern uncurling, Costa Rica
(8 votes out of 15)
My own choice: Fading tulip
Your clear winner: Machapuchare
(11 votes out of 17)
My own choice: Annapurna Range of the Himalayas seen from near Pokhara
Your narrow winner: Bicycle in the Place Saint Sulpice, Paris
(7 out of 13 votes – Faro was a close second with 5 votes)
My own choice: Ex-miner demonstrating pit machinery at Beamish, north east England
Your clear winner: In Kathmandu’s Durbar Square
(11 votes out of 19)
My own choice: Young monks in Bhaktapur, Nepal
Sunrise and sunset
Your narrow winner, and my own choice: Sunrise over the Annapurna Range
(9 votes out of 21 – the sunset over the Narayani River was a fairly close second with 6 votes)
Interestingly this was the category where votes were most split, with all four images getting at least 3 votes, yet it was one of only two in which I agreed with the majority!)
Your clear winner, and my own choice too: Young jackdaws at Studley Royal, Yorkshire
(9 votes out of 16)
Wonderful. Merci for the choices.
Thank you, and you’re welcome 😀
I’m guessing your favorites, besides being great shots, are influenced by the back story that you know.
I see why you might think that Ruth, but no – I chose based on the image itself. If I had been influenced by back story I would have chosen the rhino or toucan for wildlife, Paris for the monochrome, the fern for plants 😀
I know my back stories often influence me!
Me too – I think that’s why it took me so long to decide which were my own picks 😀
winning pictures all around 🙂
Thank you 😊
Regína Hrönn Ragnarsdóttir
How wonderful – I love all your photos, Sarah, and I am still learning from you, you for sure have an eye for photography 🙂
Thanks so much Regina, but I know from all your wonderful Iceland landscape shots that you have a great eye too 😘
I am happy to see some of my winners here
That’s great Tanja 🙂 Thanks for joining in!
I agree with the readers and you.😀 They are all worthy. The Fishtail photo would get my vote just because the shape of its summit and the way it rises so sharply from the surrounding terrain makes it a very impressive mountain regardless of how it is photographed.
Yes, Fishtail is very impressive in its own right. Maybe that’s why it’s NOT my own choice, as it’s almost too easy to get a good shot of it!
I missed the voting but I agree with Margaret. It would have been hard because I like them all. 🙂
Thank you Janet 😀
It seems I missed that exercise, but based on what I see here, I would have voted with the majority except for monochrome and street. I liked your picks better on those two. My overall favorite is the jackdaws. That is a crisp, balanced and beautifully composed photo.
Thanks Suzanne – I’m glad you liked that shot of the ex-miner as no one else apart from me seemed to do so! The jackdaws on the other hand were a very popular choice 🙂
All are wonderful, and though I didn’t vote -missed that somehow- I mostly agree with the majority! 🙂
Thank you Susanne – and see my reply to Margaret below 😀
I feel a real meanie now, as I didn’t realise you actually intended us to vote. But it would have been too hard anyway!
Don’t feel mean, voting wasn’t compulsory 😆 Although I did say ‘Please let me know in the comments your preferred option in each [category]’, so … 🤣🤣
Can’t read, me …