Consulting the rules of composition before taking a photograph is like consulting the laws of gravity before going for a walk
Edward Weston
It’s true that once we’ve learned to walk as a toddler we no longer think about how to do it (unless perhaps if recovering from an injury). In the same way, once we learn some composition techniques, we no longer need to ‘rehearse’ them in our minds before taking a photo; they become instinctive. Incidentally, I do prefer the word ‘techniques’ to ‘rules’, as it’s less prescriptive.
But whether you study and follow the ‘rules’ of composition, or prefer to take a more relaxed approach to photography, there’s no denying that certain compositions are especially pleasing to the eye and impactful.
This week Patti asks us to think about a particular form of framing our shots. We’re most of us used to the idea that an arch or doorway or overhanging branch will create the illusion of a frame around a scene. But Patti introduces the idea of framing with layers, thinking about the foreground, middle ground and background of our images. I like to think of this not so much as framing as in terms of stage sets. The set designer uses the flats on either side of the stage to create the illusion of depth, and we can do the same in composing our photos.
I’ve had a hunt through my archives to find some images that I think illustrate this concept. I hope you agree! My feature photo is a view of the rock stacks of Rialto Beach on the Olympic Peninsula in Washington State, with the Quillayute River in the middle ground, framed by bushes in the foreground.
I really should read the small print when preparing these challenge posts! I noted too late that Patti asks for up to three images, but by then I’d selected rather more than that, edited and uploaded them. So I can’t resist sharing them all!

The Mekong River near Sopchem, Laos
Foreground: beach and local woman
Middle ground: boat and river
Background: wooded mountain slopes

Done Deng Island, Mekong River, Laos
Foreground: beach, washing and jetty
Middle ground: river and far shore
Background: misty mountains

Bai Tu Long Bay, Vietnam
Foreground: fishermen and boat
Middle ground: the nearest rock stack
Background: distant hazy rock and sea

Glass Beach, Fort Bragg, California
Foreground: gull and red-tinted ice plant
Middle ground: series of similar rocks receding
Background: misty pine trees
A wet day on the rue de Rivoli, Paris
Foreground: red café tables and chairs
Middle ground: passer-by on the far pavement
Background: autumn trees and (just visible) the Louvre


Parisian wedding shoot
Foreground: the happy couple and stone balustrade
Middle ground: lawns and trees
Background: the Eiffel Tower

Florence from the Basilica di San Miniato al Monte
Foreground: yellow house framed by autumn trees
Middle ground: the historic centre of the city with the Duomo and Palazzo Vecchio
Background: the Tuscan hills which surround the city

Cemetery and old church, Taos Pueblo, New Mexico
Foreground: crosses in the cemetery
Middle ground: the old adobe church
Background: trees and distant mountains
56 Comments
wetanddustyroads
Beautiful photos to illustrate depth (I would have a hard time finding these among my photos, but after looking at your pictures and descriptions, I think there may be quite a few in our archive). I like the ones of the Mekong River, as well as Florence.
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you very much Corna 😊 I think this is just a different way of looking at and considering our photos. I was pleased to be able to find these examples without too much searching!
Ritva Sillanmäki Photography
These are so well composed and the locations are stunning, the have so much mood in them. You know your way with the camera and compositions, that is evident here and in all your posts
Sarah Wilkie
Very many thanks Ritva, I really appreciate your feedback 😊😊
Leya
I loved all of your choices – they are perfect (as usual…)! The New Mexico one is stunning, the mood and the colours. My favourite if I must have one only!
Sarah Wilkie
Aw, thank you so much 😊 I have special memories of our visit to Taos Pueblo, it was a really atmospheric and fascinating place.
Sofia Alves
Love your initial quote (so true!) and all your photos, Sarah. Not picking favourites this week, it’s impossible 🙂
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks so much Sofia ☺️ I’m glad you liked the quote as well as the photos, and picking favourites is always optional!!
equinoxio21
Excellent. Comme toujours… Maybe if I learn from you long enough, I’ll end up improving… (Though not with an IPhone methinks.)
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you 😊 Phone cameras are so good these days that I expect you could capture similar scenes to most of these!
equinoxio21
For some strange reason, I haven’t found one with a good Zoom. The day one comes out…
Sarah Wilkie
That’s very true – if I go beyond x2 on mine the quality starts to diminish. I prefer to shoot wider and crop later, but there’s a limit to what you can do that way too. However for these sorts of scenes I maintain a phone would suffice 😀 Although I think the Halong Bay one might have been taken with a fair degree of zoom? Yes, I just checked the metadata, and that one was zoomed in, as was Glass Beach to some extent. None of the others however!
grandmisadventures
great examples of layers and depth
Sarah Wilkie
Many thanks Meg 🙂
Klausbernd
Hi Sarah
We like your pictures from Paris and Florence. Like Yvonne wrote, nice 3-D-Effect.
Thanks for showing
The Fab Four of Cley
🙂 🙂 🙂 🙂
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you very much, I’m pleased you liked the effect 🙂
the eternal traveller
This is another lovely collection. I particularly enjoyed the wedding photo – every time we travel we always see at least one wedding and it’s almost become an expectation now. That couple had a beautiful background for their photos.
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you very much Carol 😊 I always look out for wedding shoots when we travel and try to sneak a few shots myself – I have quite a few now!
the eternal traveller
We do too. It’s a tradition!
Leanne Cole
These are wonderful Sarah, they all work so well for the challenge. I can see all three in each image.
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks so much Leanne – I’m glad you could see the three ‘grounds’ in these shots 😊
Cath Moore
such gorgeous examples…..I just really love the cemetery & old church
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you very much Cath 😊 Taos Pueblo was an amazing place – full of history and so atmospheric!
Joanne
Excellent pictures, all showing outstanding framing and composition. Your instincts are quite good. The rue de Rivoli – The red chairs are inspired. The Parisian wedding – Similarly terrific composition; including the tower is another inspired choice. The picture of Florence and the Tuscan hills is another fabulous shot.
Sarah Wilkie
Very many thanks Joanne 😊 Regarding the Parisian wedding, the official photographer had set the scene, I simply took advantage of it!
Tina Schell
A perfect set of examples – each meeting the brief perfectly. Loved your choices this week. I especially love when you catch people in your amazing scenes.
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you very much Tina 😊 Sometimes I try to avoid having people in my shots but quite often they can really add to the scene.
restlessjo
How could Patti not approve of your wonderful illustrations of her theme? I do! xx
Sarah Wilkie
Aw, thanks so much Jo 😘
photobyjohnbo
Wonderful examples, Sarah! My favorite is the photo at Fort Bragg with that ethereal background.
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you John ☺️ There was a lot of spray that morning and you’re right, it did create an ethereal effect in the sunlight.
margaret21
Text book landscape shots – and that’s a compliment, not an insult! But my favourite is the Glass Beach, Fort Bragg, California. The seagull adds that certain je ne sais quoi.
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks so much Margaret 😊 As I said to Teresa, I loved that stretch of coastline in California, and the light was perfect for photography that morning, with the spray creating the illusion of mist and catching the early sunlight.
pattimoed
Hi Sarah. Super images, all beautifully composed. I especially love your image of the old cemetery and your images from Laos and Vietnam. No worries about having more than 3 images. I enjoyed them all!
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you very much Patti 😊 Both for the lovely comment and also forgiving the excess of images here!
Teresa
All amazing shots, Sarah. But for me the Mekong and the seagull in California are my faves But really… all of them haha
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks so much Teresa 😊 I loved that stretch of coastline in California – the light was perfect that morning and the seagull was just a bonus!
bushboy
All aspects of the challenge all rolled into each fabulous photo. Well done Sarah
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you very much Brian 😊
Vicki
Wonderful examples, Sarah.
I suspect you instinctively frame the shot with layers in your photos. Perhaps that comes from experience and composition. It certainly works in the examples you’ve given. (Note: I never seem to read the sentence to post only ‘x’ amount of examples for a challenge and I’m so glad you posted more than 3).
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks so much Vicki 😊 Actually when I started to look for appropriate images I found lots that had two layers but relatively few with the three that Patti was looking for (unless you count the sky as the third, which I don’t unless it is a particularly eye-catching one). And I’m glad I’m not the only one who tends to overlook those instructions!
notesoflifeuk
Wonderful photos. I can’t wait see why you chose more than 3!
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you – the only reason I chose more than three is that I didn’t see that instruction and I always go over the top!
Susanne Swanson
Beautiful compositions! And of course, you caught me with Rialto Beach! 🙂
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you very much Susanne 😊 I had several of Rialto and the other Olympic beaches that could have worked for this challenge!
Egídio
Wow! These photos really stand out and show the three planes in photography. Like you, I also overlooked the request for three images. I posted 5, but within an hour, I realized my mistake and removed the extra two images. It ended up being for the better for me as the original reply focused on one location. The extra images are featured in today’s post with an entirely different focus.
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks so much Egidio 😊 I admire your discipline in removing those already included images! I did delete some from the ones I’d uploaded (there were originally twelve) but I couldn’t bring myself to cut it back so drastically when I’d done all the work of selecting and editing them!
Egídio
Thanks, Sarah. For me, it was easier because I wanted to use those images for my wall post. I just had to write new text and add one more image.
Monkey's Tale
The Laos and Vietnam ones carried me back to those sites, but my favourite is the surprise red chairs on the Rue de Rivoli. Maggie
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you Maggie 🙂 That Rue de Rivoli shot was taken from inside the café where we’d taken shelter from the rain and were enjoying a couple of croques monsieur to cheer ourselves up after a washout of a morning!
Anne Sandler
Great illustrations for this challenge, Sarah. I’m so glad you “couldn’t resist” because I enjoyed all of them.
Sarah Wilkie
Many thanks Anne 😊 I’m glad my ‘over the top’ approach wasn’t an issue for you!
Sue
Great post,excellent descriptions of your image creation, Sarah!The photographs from Laos and Vietnam were particularly interesting, and the one from Florence struck a chord as I saw a similar view 46 years ago…
Sarah Wilkie
Thanks so much Sue 😊 I’m glad to have transported you back to Florence!
Yvonne Dumsday
What wonderful examples you have used that so aptly illustrate those rules you mention. Your examples almost look to be 3-d.
Sarah Wilkie
Thank you Yvonne 😀 3D is exactly the impression I was hoping for!